Is Malik Willis getting a free pass for the Miami Dolphins' offensive struggles, or are fans giving up on him too soon?
With the Dolphins sitting at 1-7, O.J. McDuffie, Seth Levit, and Mike Oliva reunite for another spirited Fish Tank × DolphinsTalk crossover, and the biggest question facing Miami takes center stage: Is Malik Willis really the quarterback of the future?
Mike believes the Dolphins may already have their answer. Willis could serve as a bridge quarterback, but Miami needs to start seriously considering its next franchise QB.
Juice isn't ready to give up on Willis, but he's increasingly concerned about the young quarterback's decision-making, reluctance to check down, and inability to consistently elevate the offense. And with Willis battling a groin injury, Juice makes a surprising suggestion: Sit him down and give Kyle McCord a chance against Indianapolis!
Seth pushes back, arguing that evaluating Willis after just eight games in a rebuilding season—behind an inconsistent offensive line and with inexperienced receivers—is premature. Is Miami being patient with its quarterback, or making excuses for him?
The guys also tackle several other major Dolphins storylines:
Zach Sieler's season-ending injury: After playing nearly an entire game against Detroit with a torn biceps, has the veteran defensive lineman played his final game in Miami?
The quarterback dilemma: Should Miami use a premium draft pick on a quarterback, or continue building around Willis while developing a young prospect?
The 2027 NFL Draft: Is there really a quarterback worth taking near the top of the first round? The guys debate the risks of reaching for an unproven prospect.
The offensive line: How much blame should Miami's struggling protection shoulder for Willis' inconsistent performances?
The Dolphins' future: With the trade deadline arriving and another disappointing season unfolding, what should Jeff Hafley and Jon-Eric Sullivan prioritize?
Plus, Mike teases another rant about opposing fans taking over Hard Rock Stadium!
THE BIG QUESTION: Are Dolphins fans being too hard on Malik Willis, or have we already seen enough to know he's not the long-term answer?
Let us know in the comments!
The Fish Tank is presented by:
Van Horn Law Group
https://www.vanhornlawgroup.com/
🐬 Fish Tank: The Deep End — Get exclusive bonus content, behind-the-scenes stories, and more:
